Christmas time is a time of year where families from all around the world, no matter the different and unique traditions celebrated, come together and celebrate the holidays in their own way.
One of the most iconic and famous aspects of the Christmas season is putting up a Christmas tree, a tradition with roots stretching back to ancient times in Germany, where people brought evergreen trees into their homes and decorated them with ornaments to mark the holiday.
This practice spread throughout Europe and eventually to the Western Hemisphere, where the Christmas tree became a major symbol for Christmas time.
But now, for many families, there is one major choice to make when it comes to Christmas trees: Should they get a real or artificial tree?
Both options contain their own pros and cons, and the decision often boils down to personal preference and lifestyle considerations. Let’s break down the key points to consider in the debate between real vs. artificial Christmas trees.
For some, the unique and cozy experience of a real Christmas tree, the nostalgic pine scent, the feel of the needles, the feeling of a classic Christmas experience, and the rustic textures is truly irreplaceable.
Real trees are obviously a natural product, and as they grow, they absorb carbon dioxide, releasing oxygen and supporting wildlife. Many tree farms also replant trees each year, which can make the process relatively sustainable, as long as the tees are disposed of responsibly.
Despite this, real trees still aren’t perfect. The tree has to be cut down, transported, and eventually decomposed after the holiday season. They also require lots of manual care, like watering and cleaning up all of the fallen needles. And for some, real trees present allergy risks or safety concerns, as they can be a fire hazard if they dry out.
Artificial trees have come a very long way in terms of quality and realism. They are really convenient as you don’t need to buy a new one every year, unlike real trees, and they are generally low maintenance. Many are even pre-lit, which means a lot less hassle with tangled lights.
On top of this, since they last several years, they can be a much more economic option over time, as even though they may be more expensive than real Christmas trees, it becomes much more worth the price as you can use it every year, increasing the value to a reasonable rate.
On the downside, fake trees are typically made from PVC and metal, materials that require significant energy to produce. They may emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs), and when finally discarded, they often end up in landfills. To offset the environmental impact, experts suggest keeping an artificial tree for at least ten years, but even then, they do not decompose like real trees do.
Ultimately, the choice between a real and an artificial Christmas tree all depends on what aspects matter most to you. If sustainability is a priority, want a classic and nostalgic Christmas experience, and you are committed to a proper disposal, a real tree might better resonate with your values.
On the other hand, if convenience and cost savings over multiple years are important, an artificial tree could be the better option for you.
At the end of the day, the best tree is the one that brings you and your family joy, fits with holiday traditions for you, and makes the season meaningful. Whether you;re a fan of the real tree’s natural charm or the artificial tree’s easy maintenance, both choices allow us to create cherished memories and celebrate the season with loved ones.